As surgical wait lists develop, Canada’s personal clinics money in

As surgical wait lists develop, Canada’s personal clinics money in

It is a contentious actuality in a rustic with a common medicare system: Canadians will pay to sidestep the queue for surgical procedures with lengthy ready lists, equivalent to hip and knee replacements.

Non-public clinics throughout Canada are promoting to potential sufferers that inside weeks they will get surgical procedures that usually take six months or extra below provincial well being plans. The worth for a single hip or knee alternative runs within the vary of $20,000 to $28,000, relying on the clinic. 

Within the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic driving up surgical wait instances, there’s some proof suggesting a rising variety of Canadians are pulling out their wallets to pay privately. 

  • Do you will have a narrative about ready for a surgical procedure or paying for personal medical care? Share it with us in an electronic mail to [email protected]. We wish to hear from you.

The pattern is elevating issues in regards to the potential for personal clinics to empty extra well being professionals away from the already strained public system, and it is upsetting fears that two-tier well being care is changing into a actuality.

The personal Duval Clinic in Laval, Que. — the place surgeons solely do hip and knee replacements for fee-paying sufferers — has seen a big improve in demand over the previous few years, says its medical director, Dr. Pascal-André Vendittoli. 

“We have quadrupled the variety of circumstances we do on the clinic,” stated Vendittoli in an interview with CBC Information. 

“There are an increasing number of sufferers keen to pay for his or her hip or knee alternative as a result of they see that it’s nearly unimaginable to get their remedy within the public system.”

‘Greatest funding’ says affected person

Mike Johansen, 62, of Edmonton spent $23,500 for a hip alternative on the Duval Clinic. 

“Greatest funding I ever made,” Johansen stated in an interview. “I do not take a look at myself as an individual who jumped to the entrance of the queue, I bought out of the queue.” 

Mike Johansen is pictured walking down a staircase in his home.
Mike Johansen, 62, of Edmonton spent $23,500 to get a hip alternative at a personal clinic in Quebec somewhat than wait 18 months for the surgical procedure by means of Alberta’s public well being system. (Scott Neufeld/CBC)

Earlier than the operation, Johansen’s hip downside made nearly any motion painful. 

“About 70, 80 per cent of the time I used to be laying in mattress. That was the one manner that there actually wasn’t a complete lot of ache,” he stated. 

His physician instructed him his await surgical procedure by means of Alberta Well being Providers could be 18 to 24 months. He bought into the Duval clinic in simply two months. 

The Clearpoint Health Network building on Dixon Road in Toronto.
Clearpoint Well being Community is the biggest chain of personal surgical clinics in Canada, with 53 working rooms in 14 areas, together with this one in Toronto specializing in orthopedic surgical procedure. (Paul Smith/CBC)

Hip and knee replacements are among the many most incessantly carried out surgical procedures within the Canadian well being system, and include a number of the longest wait instances. 

Hospitals did almost 139,000 joint replacements in 2019-2020, in accordance with the Canadian Institute for Well being Info (CIHI). Its analysis places the common value per operation at $12,223, which suggests the personal clinics are charging sufferers roughly double what the surgical procedure prices provincial medicare methods. 

CIHI’s most up-to-date wait-time figures present that simply 65 per cent of hip replacements and 59 per cent of knee replacements have been achieved inside the nationwide commonplace of six months after session with a surgeon.

The personal sector’s potential function in tackling surgical wait lists is firmly within the highlight proper now: 

  • Ontario unveiled a plan final month that opens the door to for-profit clinics performing endoscopies and hip and knee replacements, paid for by the Ontario Well being Insurance coverage Plan (OHIP). 

  • Each Manitoba and Saskatchewan are trying to cope with backlogs by paying personal clinics exterior the province to do surgical procedures. 

  • Alberta introduced in January that it is contracting Canadian Surgical procedure Options to carry out greater than 3,000 orthopedic surgical procedures coated by the provincial medicare plan. 

Canadian Surgical procedure Options is a Calgary department of an organization known as Clearpoint Well being Community, the nation’s largest chain of personal surgical clinics. 

WATCH | Why sufferers are paying to get surgical procedure sooner:

How Canadians are paying to leap the queue for surgical procedure

Practically 140,000 individuals get a hip or knee alternative every year in Canadian hospitals and wait instances can run to greater than a 12 months. Non-public surgical clinics across the nation are promoting that sufferers can get surgical procedures achieved in just some weeks, in the event that they pay.

Clearpoint is wholly owned by Kensington Non-public Fairness Fund, and it was created in 2019 by means of a $35 million buy of personal clinics. 

The corporate introduced an growth in January, taking Clearpoint to 53 working rooms throughout 14 surgical clinics, touching each province from British Columbia to Quebec. 

Most sufferers should go away house province to pay

Clearpoint officers didn’t reply to repeated requests from CBC Information for an interview. 

Whereas the corporate says 90 per cent of the surgical procedures it performs are publicly funded, Clearpoint additionally markets to Canadians ready for care within the public system that they will get hip and knee replacements achieved a lot sooner by paying privately.

“Keep away from lengthy wait instances,” says the web site of Surgical Options Community, a division of Clearpoint. “After your preliminary surgical session, surgical procedure can typically be scheduled inside just a few weeks.”

The corporate explains a catch to sufferers who wish to pay: they’re going to probably have to go away their house province for the operation. 

An image captured from a webpage with a stock photo of surgical staff.
The web site of Surgical Options Community, a division of Clearpoint Well being Community, describes how Canadian sufferers will pay privately for surgical procedure by travelling to a different province. (

The Canada Well being Act prohibits extra-billing. What meaning is docs are banned from charging sufferers greater than the medicare price for an “insured service” — any medically crucial process that’s coated by provincial well being plans. 

In provinces apart from Quebec, the place the system differs, personal clinics get round that ban by working solely on sufferers from different provinces. 

This loophole is opened up by how the Canada Well being Act and the provinces outline an insured service. 

A medically crucial non-emergency surgical procedure equivalent to a hip alternative is an insured service once you’re in your house province. If you go to one other province, non-emergency surgical procedure will not be insured. 

The upshot: a physician in a personal clinic in Toronto can not cost an Ontario affected person for a hip alternative, however can cost somebody who has flown in from some other province for that exact same operation.

CBC Information obtained an electronic mail from a Clearpoint official to a potential hip alternative affected person in Ontario. 

Dr. David Urbach is pictured inside an operating room at Women’s College Hospital in Toronto.
Dr. David Urbach, who leads the division of surgical procedure at Ladies’s School Hospital in Toronto, says personal pay clinics are making wait lists worse within the public system. (Mike Crawley/CBC)

“Sadly, as a result of authorities rules, you’re unable to have personal surgical procedure in your house province. You would wish to journey to Calgary for the process,” stated the e-mail, which additionally priced the surgical procedure at $28,000. 

“It isn’t consistent with the ideas of the Canada Well being Act,” stated Dr. David Urbach, chief of surgical procedure at Ladies’s School Hospital in Toronto. 

Urbach argues that the expansion in private-paid surgical procedures worsens wait lists by luring medical workers away from public hospitals. 

“It will increase wait instances for the remainder of the people who find themselves nonetheless within the public system due to the lack of assets from that public system into the personal system,” stated Urbach in an interview. 

He says governments shouldn’t be trying to the personal sector to shorten surgical wait lists, however might obtain the identical aim by higher investing in public hospitals.

As proof, Urbach gestures on the location of his interview: a state-of-the artwork working room, not in use for surgical procedure on a weekday morning, as a result of medical workers aren’t obtainable. 

A doctor looks at a computer screen showing images of a patient's knee replacement surgery.
Hospitals did almost 139,000 joint replacements in 2019-2020, in accordance with the Canadian Institute for Well being Info. (Louis-Marie Philidor/CBC)

“If the hospital had funding, if this hospital had staffing, it could possibly be used to supply all types of surgical procedures,” he stated. 

‘No manner I might afford … that’

The expansion in personal surgical clinics leaves Saskatchewan resident Vicki Macdonald, 59, fearful for the way forward for the well being system. Within the birthplace of Canadian medicare, Macdonald spent two years ready for knee surgical procedure. 

“I bought slower and slower in my strolling,” stated Macdonald in an interview at her house in Kronau, Sask.

“If you end up in that a lot ache, it actually takes a toll in your emotional and psychological well-being.” 

She discovered that folks have been shortening their waits by paying for his or her surgical procedures in personal clinics exterior the province, however dismissed the thought for herself. 

“There isn’t a manner I might afford to do one thing like that,” Macdonald stated. “These that may afford it will probably get it, after which we who want it simply as dangerous are getting left behind.” 

Vicki Macdonald is pictured in her home.
Vicki Macdonald waited two years for a knee alternative within the Saskatchewan public well being system and says there was ‘no manner’ she might have afforded to pay privately for the surgical procedure. (Richard Agecoutay/CBC)

Urbach says the obvious rise in individuals keen to pay privately for surgical procedures saddens him.

“What it tells me is we’re not addressing the wants of the inhabitants. We should always have the ability to present the companies that folks want in an affordable timeframe,” Urbach stated. 

“What we have to do is create the varieties of system modifications so that folks aren’t pushed to pay out of pocket or hunt down two-tiered care.” 

The one jurisdiction the place residents can go for personal surgical procedure with out leaving the province is Quebec, a results of a 2005 Supreme Courtroom of Canada ruling that applies strictly to the Quebec well being system. 

In British Columbia, Dr. Brian Day has tried to steer courts that sufferers ought to have the correct to pay for personal care when wait instances within the public system are too lengthy. 

Day, proprietor of the personal Cambie Surgical procedure Centre, misplaced on the B.C. Courtroom of Enchantment in July 2022 and is asking the Supreme Courtroom of Canada to think about his case.